Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Observer's avatar

"The best advice comes from the Hadiths......He who hurts a dhimmi (citizen) hurts me, and he who hurts me annoys Allah” (Al-Tabarani)".

Isn't invoking the Hadith already acceding ruling authority to Islam, with perhaps no room to any form of recognition to non-Islamic authority? Furthermore, isn't the status of a dhimmi classically that of a non-Muslim that is a second-class subject to dominant Muslims, and have to pay jizya (poll tax) for 'protection'.

But then again, that may be what an Islamic society, any kind of Islamic society, ultimately turns into. That is, a society ruled by Islamic laws. Brunei already implemented staunch Islamic laws some years ago. And Indonesia is also showing signs of becoming more staunch. One such sign, the hordes of Muslims demanding Jakarta governor Ahok be removed for alleged blasphemy and they got their wish. Another sign, reports that all 24 Muslim-majority provinces (out of a total of 34) in Indonesia now have mandatory Islamic dress codes for girls and women at various levels (https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/07/21/indonesian-women-speak-out-dress-codes).

Expand full comment
Dax Xenox Chan's avatar

In the 1970s after the coup-Tengku was forced to resign and Razak took over the helm of Malaysia ( no elections) the Muslim government had a free reign to do 'all and sundry'. The promotion of Malay nationalism, changing the media in schools, history books, road signs, among many other policies -creation of the NEP eroded the state of its uniqueness-multiracial, multicultural and multireligious character. Over the last 50 days -the P Ramlee era disappeared. Malaysia must be looked at as Afghanistan was in the 1960s and 1970s. Today, Malaysia is 'on track' to be the next Taliban like state. With the inclusion of Bangladeshi, Pakistani, Indonesian, Arab cultures through marriage and other means the "Malay identity" is gone. Politicians divide Malaysian by promoting anti-racial hate. The Non-Malays with very little from the government (a blessing in hindsight) are/were resilient and still have become successful, while Malays have been afflicted by corruption, and roll back in education etc. Malays are reaping what they allowed their politicians to sow. The NEP was a total failure.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts