Discover more from Murray Hunter
UMNO-PAS will win the next general election
This is why Bersatu and PH are hesitant about GE15
This was originally published Oct 5, 2019. This was when PH was still in power and heavily criticized for not performing. I have updated this article with some notes.
The national unity charter signed last month by long-time political adversaries Parti Islam se-Malaysia (PAS) and the United Malays National Organization (UMNO) to uphold the interests of Malays and designate Islam as the country’s official religion probably means the ruling Pakatan Harapan (now PN under Muhyiddin) coalition will be a one-term government. A Muhyiddin led government will have little chance of surviving without having a solid coalition behind it.
Before the last general election, UMNO and the ruling Barisan Nasional were tired and deeply mired in corruption. Former Premier Mahathir Mohamed, leading his own party, Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia, tapped into the loyalty of older Malays, gaining trust from the heartlands to save Malaysia from UMNO. He headed a coalition made up of Anwar Ibraham’s Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR), composed largely of rural moderate ethnic Malays; Parti Amanah Negara, composed of rural ethnic Malays; the Democratic Action Party (DAP), dominated by ethnic Chinese; and smaller splinter parties.
The new mathematics created by the UMNO-PAS coalition means that the ruling coalition must take dramatic action over the next three years if it is to hold on. (Muhyiddin will need a solid alliance – if that is possible) So far there appears no such calculus. Pakatan’s election has resulted in one disappointment after another, especially for those who expected political reform, as factions within the coalition attack each other, with little attention paid to governing. In addition, ugly racial bigotry and religious fervor are on the rise. The Pakatan government is starting to be perceived as betraying those who voted for them as indicated by a series of by-election losses last year. (Now 18 months after being ousted from office, the anger is reflected upon Muhyiddin for coming to power through the backdoor. Disappointment has been projected away from the PKR and DAP towards Muhyiddin and the Azmin Ali grouping).
Pakatan’s mandate to govern
The win for Pakatan was not like the 2008 electoral tsunami in which the then-Pakatan Rakyat was swept into power across five states, achieving 47.5 percent of the popular vote. There was no increase in aggregate votes in the 2018 election compared to previous elections. Pakatan received only 45.68 percent of the popular vote, down on the 50.87 percent in 2013. (This is the crucial point here. PH got votes in the right places just to squeeze through for a majority, with Mahathir chipping away at UMNO loyalists, which won’t happen this time around).
However, in a first-past-the-post (FPTP) electoral system, it’s where the votes are cast, rather than the aggregate vote. Pakatan gained enough seats to form a government with PAS contesting every peninsula seat, creating three-cornered contests, diluting the Barisan vote. (A coordinated UMNO-PAS candidate list will help them pick up more constituencies).
Pakatan picked up seats in the Malay rural heartlands of Kedah, Terengganu, Perak, Selangor, Negri Sembilan, Melaka and Johor. Only about 20 percent of those Pakatan picked up came from urban areas. The rest came from winning four extra constituencies in Sarawak and eight by its partner Warisan in Sabah.
Around a dozen UMNO defectors later crossed over, mainly to Mahathir’s Bersatu. In addition, defectors from Sabah UMNO, in near collapse, crossed over to Warisan, giving Pakatan a comfortable parliamentary majority. Pakatan also won over state governments in Kedah, Perak, Negri Sembilan, Melaka, Johor, and Sabah. (UMNO Sabah was much stronger in the last state election).
Pakatan’s new gains built upon the traditional support base of the Democratic Action Party, anchored in the urban and township areas of Penang, Perak, Selangor, Klang Valley, Selangor, Melaka, and Johor. In East Malaysia, the DAP has a smattering of seats in urban concentrations in Sarawak and Sabah, supplemented with a number of Parti Keadilan Rakyat seats, where support has gradually grown. Pakatan’s traditional support base remains relatively resistant to swings against the coalition, with about 60 or so safe seats.
Many of the DAP and PKR seats have been gerrymandered by the Barisan into above-average numbers of registered voters, such as the Kuala Lumpur suburb of Damansara with 121,263 registered against a national average of 67,300. These seats are malapportioned to dilute their national representation. (DAP support will most probably rise once again in GE15, but due to constituency malapportionment, this will not result in the DAP gaining many more constituencies).
However, Pakatan owes its victory not to faithful urban electors but rather voters from the rural Malay heartlands who listened to Mahathir’s message. A change of government was only actually enabled through the spoiler PAS although Pakatan also owes victory to the voters of Sabah and Sarawak. (This is where the battleground will be. UMNO doesn’t have Mahathir chipping away at their support next election. Najib’s Bossku persona is a strange phenomenon that may have a plus in some rural areas. UMNO can claim that PH messed things up, and Muhyiddin wasn’t much better. UMNO is therefore the best candidate to govern).
Consequently, Pakatan’s reform mandate is more fiction than fact. Pakatan’s real mandate is replacing UMNO with a viable alternative and fulfilling its promises to Sabah and Sarawak. Meeting that mandate to the satisfaction of the swing seats Pakatan picked up last election is the only way it can stay in government.
The next general election
Political dynamics can change very quickly. However, we can employ three simple assumptions:
1. There will be no three-way political contests between UMNO and PAS.
2. UMNO and PAS supporters will accept the new political alliance, and
3. General voting patterns can be expected to remain similar to last election.
That would mean Pakatan’s parliamentary representation would decrease from the 121 seats they currently hold to around 83. UMNO-PAS representation would increase from 97 to 123, allowing it to comfortably form the next federal government. Pakatan would also lose Kedah and Perak at the state level along with Melaka (which has already basically happened at state level now). Negri Sembilan would be a cliff-hangar. Pakatan might narrowly hang onto Selangor but lose 12 seats in the Johor State Assembly. DAP would hold onto Penang without any problems.
Five (former) cabinet ministers – Saifuddin Abdullah, Saifuddin Nausution Ismail, Mohd Redzuan Md Yusof, Baru Bian, and Mujahad Yusof Rawa who were elected with PAS’s help would lose their parliamentary seats. Education minister Maszlee Malik and Youth and Sports Minister Syed Saddiq are also likely to lose. Assuming Mahathir, who was born in 1925 and would then be 97 or 98 years of age, leaves politics, Langkawi would probably go to UMNO-PAS. Mahathir’s son Mukhriz in the neighboring federal seat of Jerlun would also lose his seat, as would Anwar’s daughter Nurul Izzah if she recontests her seat in Permatang Puah (However, this seat should Nurual recontest would be a very interesting one to watch). All but one of the UMNO defectors to Bersatu, Mustapha Mohamed would likely and end their political careers (No doubt UMNO would contest these seats fiercely).
Bersatu would be decimated to only three seats, Amanah five, PKR 35s. DAP would only lose one seat (Now maybe pick up 1-3 seats).
The result would be worse if the trends shown in the last few by-elections are any indication. For example, a 5 percent drop in turnout of Malays who supported Pakatan in the past general election would result in the loss of even more seats. A 10-20 percent drop in non-Malay turnout in mixed electorates would lose Pakatan another 10-20 seats. (The events leading to a backdoor government will give PKR a new life electorally. They will hold and most probably pick up on their vote. However, these votes will fall in urban constituencies they are already holding, so lead to only small gains).
New voters might offset some of the losses. However, around half of the new voters will be in gerrymandered urban areas. This would favor UMNO-PAS, with new voters in the Malay heartlands identifying much more with their Islamic identity than previous generations. (New voters will be 50/50).
Pakatan would live and die on Malay-centric politics
Pakatan’s by-election losses in Cameron Highlands, Semenyih, and Rantau indicate that the coalition no longer enjoys the same level of support it had in GE14. The Tanjung Plai seat in the coming by-election in Johor is notionally an UMNO-PAS seat with an approximately 12 percent majority, based on GE14 election figures. In the current environment, this deficit for Pakatan would almost be impossible to bridge unless other factors come into the equation, such as the stature of the contesting candidates. A more than probable win to UMNO-PAS would prove the logic behind their alliance is correct.
With many of the seats Pakatan holds being notionally UMNO-PAS, retaining them will be an uphill task, even if Pakatan can improve its electoral popularity. Voters in the Malay heartlands, who are concerned with the cost of living, making an adequate income, and seeing their children get employment after graduation will determine the next election. They don’t understand the 1MDB scandal and the long-running trial. Personal wellbeing and local infrastructure development are what is important.
Middle-class Malaysians who are disappointed with Pakatan’s failure to deliver reforms are primarily situated in urban and mixed urban/rural seats where incumbent MPs have large majorities. A decline in support by this group won’t result in a loss of too many seats for Pakatan.
The next state election in Sarawak, due by 2021 will indicate the support for Pakatan and UMNO-PAS. Sabah is always a wild card due to the common practice of switching party allegiances by MPs after elections.
UMNO-PAS will play on the insecurities of the rural electorates and paint Pakatan as anti-Malay and anti-Islam, which will be returned by Pakatan politicians with similar rhetoric. Pakatan can hope that the UMNO-PAS alliance falters and implodes, which could well happen given PAS’s track record with previous alliances. People within UMNO and PAS unhappy with seat allocations will sabotage their own alliance candidates in some seats. Supporters of UMNO may not vote for PAS candidates and visa versa due to deep-seated hate some have for their former adversaries. This is an area that Pakatan must exploit, if they have any hope of holding onto government (or in the case today rewinning government).
UMNO could be greatly weakened electorally if their loyalists don’t vote because of discontent with the alliance. Many notable UMNO leaders weren’t at the formalization ceremony at least partly because of the lack of credibility of the leadership. Pakatan could sabotage the alliance by seeking the Registrar of Societies (ROS) to order the dissolution of UMNO due to infringements of party rules. This could greatly weaken the alliance if there is no time for UMNO to regroup. (This wont happen now, but another issue here is the jail cluster – what will happen?).
The odds are that Mahathir will retire as prime minister (now only an MP, but will he?) in the year before the next general election and not contest his seat, leaving Anwar as the spearhead of the Pakatan campaign, which would suit the UMNO-PAS leadership perfectly. (you can see Anwar preparing already).
Based on the above analysis, DAP would be left with 41 seats and PKR with 35 seats forming the opposition with a handful of Amanah and Bersatu MPs. The Mahathir era would be finished with little legacy to show. His party Bersatu would be almost destroyed without any strong successor to rebuild it. Anwar may hold the office of prime minister for a short time, fulfilling his ambition. PKR would have to rebuild the party in the post-Anwar era. Which way the party goes will depend on which faction comes out stronger electorally. (In the current scenario, Anwar has to win, he will go all out.
The key for him to win is to do well electorally and form a solid alliance with Sabah and Sarawak parties). GE15 will be more about building party alliances than winning votes. This is the battleground for UMNO, Muhyiddin and Anwar forces. The one who cements the best alliance will form the next government.
The percentage of Malays in the general population has been steadily increasing over the years. Malays represent just over 50 percent of Malaysia’s population. Malay-centric politics will be necessary to win elections. The big question is whether there are any alternative Malay-centric narratives which accommodate reform that would be acceptable to the portion of the electorate that is the kingmaker, the Malay heartlands? Otherwise, Malaysia will be trapped in the current racist-Malay-Islamic rhetoric. (From the DAP perspective, can they join an alliance and be part of government once again?)
Originally published in the Asia Sentinel 5th October 2019
You can subscribe for free emails of future articles here: